« Buffet lines and all-you-can-eat diners tremble in fear when Michael Phelps comes to town | Main | Was it girls? Or was it grills? Swimming odds and ends from Omaha »

Can Phelps become the new Tiger Woods?

It's only the second day of the U.S. Olympic swimming trials, and already, Michael Phelps has done something off-the-charts ridiculous. Last night he and his good friend Ryan Lochte engaged in a showdown that, at least for now, might go down as the best race in the history of swimming. That may sound like hyperbole, especially considering the race happened at the U.S. trials instead of the Olympics, but when you consider just how close it was over 400 meters (neither Phelps nor Lochte ever led by more than a half a body length, despite swimming four different stroke disciplines) and how fast each swimmer went (both went under the old world record) it's hard to come to any other conclusion.

Throw in the fact that the race was broadcast live on NBC, on Sunday night in prime time no less, and you can imagine there are a lot of corporate executives at 30 Rockefeller Plaza who are exchanging awkward, yet enthusiastic high fives this morning. The gamble NBC took in putting the U.S. trials on late-night television has, in some respects, already paid off. Anything Phelps does this week -- and it looks like he could have another record-setting week -- will only enhance his legend before the network cranks up its hype machine and gears up for the Beijing Olympics in August.

Although the impact is certainly not quite on the same scale, Phelps clearly has the Tiger Woods affect on the sport of swimming. He brings fresh eyeballs to the sport, the kind that otherwise could not be bothered to so much as change the channel to watch swimming. And when those fresh eyeballs do happen to show up, he rarely, if ever, disappoints. That translates into additional dollars and increased popularity. Phelps' race against Lochte last night was kind of like Rocco Mediate staring down Woods at this year's U.S. Open (although in terms of talent, Lochte is more like Sergio Garcia or Phil Mickelson). Lochte pushed Phelps in a way he's never really been pushed before, and probably should have come out on top. Phelps hadn't come within several seconds of his own world record in the 400 IM in more than a year. At the Missouri Grand Prix earlier this year, I watched he and Katie Hoff make a bet as to who could come closer to their world record in that event. Phelps went 4:13, still won easily, and was visibly annoyed as he left the pool. It reminded of me of Woods shooting 69 and stomping off the driving rage to work on his swing.

Woods' name comes up often in the swim community when people talk about Phelps. Natalie Coughlin, Katie Hoff, and Brendan Hansen all invoked the comparison this week. Matt Lauer mentioned it on the Today Show, and ESPN.com columnist Pat Forde also made the connection, arguing that in Woods' absence -- as the world's best golfer rehabs from knee surgery -- Phelps might be able to fill the void for the American sporting public.

The comparison still seems like a stretch for some, especially those who only bother to follow an Olympics sport like swimming once every four years. But what I find interesting about the comparison is that the parallels extend beyond just popularity. Like Woods, Phelps has an uncanny ability to stay calm under pressure. Other swimmers walk out of the warm-up pool with three thousand thoughts bouncing around inside their head. Phelps is able to simply slow everything down and wipe his mind clean.

"It’s always fun to see Michael really dig down and just focus under the pressure of events like this," said Bob Bowman, Phelps' coach, after last night's 400 IM. "I think that’s his best attribute. It’s always fun to see that." 

In addition, the physical transformation that Woods has helped golf undergo is analogous to the one Phelps helped revolutionize in swimming. There has been constant media chatter -- some of it so constant, it's almost absurd -- about the Speedo LZR swimsuits over the last six months and whether they're tantamount to technological doping. Why else are all these world records falling, the media keeps asking.

What that overlooks, in part, is the evolution of swimmers' bodies. Michael Phelps has an enormous wingspan, huge hands and feet, double joints, and almost no rear end. In the water, he's shaped like a rowing scull. Swimmers simply weren't shaped that way 15 and 20 years ago, the way that golfers didn't have 14-inch biceps and a six pack like Tiger Woods. When you combine that with the science of modern training, both in the weight room and at the dinner table, what you're seeing is new frontiers of sport.  

It's interesting too the way Phelps has shaped his public persona in a similar manner to Woods. Both athletes are guarded about their personal lives, and choose their words carefully with every news conference. He's not boring, he's just never controversial. I listened yesterday for an hour as Olympic swimmer Gary Hall held court with a throng of media, offering controversial and candid opinions on everything from drug use and drug testing to why politics shouldn't be a part of the Olympics.

In 100 years, I can never imagine Phelps speaking that candidly. That's not a knock on Phelps, it's just a reality. He has sponsorships to protect and an entire sport to promote. He and his advisers -- much like Woods -- have clearly decided that it's not in his best interests to rock the boat. That may frustrate swimmers like Hall, who would clearly like Phelps to speak his mind more often, but it's simply not Phelps' style.

Woods brought golf the the masses, at least for awhile, igniting interest outside the country club set, and it's possibly we're seeing some of that with Phelps as well. Swimming in the United States may never reach the heights that is has in Australia, where athletes like Ian Thorpe, Grant Hackett, Libby Lenton, and Leisel Jones are national celebrities who regularly show up in the tabloids that are Australia's equivalent of US Weekly. (Thorpe's sexuality is a matter of constant debate in his home country; every few months he politely denies rumors that he's gay.) But swimming may rise above the level of fringe sports thanks to Phelps.

After his Olympic performance four years ago, he popped up on MTV's Total Request Live and made multiple appearances on the Tonight Show. When he won seven gold medals at the FINA World Championships last year in Australia, his feat was the subject of nightly debate on ESPN's SportsCenter and Pardon the Interruption, despite the fact that there was no television coverage of the event. As the Olympics approach, Americans will see more commercials of Phelps than they will of Woods. Like it or not, he'll be a fixture in the homes of anyone who watches NBC and doesn't have a DVR (to zip through the ads).

Most baffling of all, Phelps just turned 23. Today is his birthday.

Despite all that's already happened to enhance his legend, we may be closer to the beginning than we are the end.

AP photo

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://blogs.trb.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-t.cgi/78845

Comments

Not a chance. Olympians are forgotten 2 weeks after the games are over. Swimmers don't get the almost year round coverage that golf does. Their careers aren't nearly as long either.

Another factor is that the average golfer can go play a round and maybe hit a few shots similar to Tiger. You won't see many middle aged guys jumping in a pool because of Phelps.

Don't get me wrong, Phelps is an outstanding swimmer, but he's not in Tiger's league.

Phelps and Lochte are the greatest athletes alive right now.

Tiger Woods is a fine athlete -- may be the most popular golfer ever, but the comparison between Woods and Phelps and Lochte is a slight.

There is no comparison between the physical work outs that swimmers Phelps and Lochte and golfer's walk in the Woods.

It is twisted fate for Lochte to be such a strong swimmer and be born in the time of Michael Phelps.

Lets hope this Olympics gets more people into the pool for fitness. That is a more important measure than Woods Phelps contrast.

Keep it coming Michael and Ryan.

Best fishes,

Timothy

Tim, I totally agree with your point, in that there is simply no comparison between the kind of conditioning Tiger puts himself through and the conditioning that Phelps and Lochte put themselves through. I doubt Tiger would argue either, although he does have some of the most unbelievable hand-to-eye coordination of any athlete ever, and hand-to-eye coordination, while unmeasurable, is something we have to take into account when we talk about athletic ability. But what I am saying is that Phelps and Woods are similar in the way they've altered our perception of what's possible, as well as in their approaches to both athletic competition and business.

What Ryan is doing right now is simply amazing, and you're right, he may be cursed with having simply been born in the wrong era, but you could make the same argument of Mickelson, who might very well have been Tom Watson if not for Tiger Woods. I wouldn't count Lochte out in Beijing by any means though. There is a small, but growing, sect of the swimming community that believes Lochte might just be the guy who could win five or six gold medals at the 2008 Olympics. Could be a stretch, but it's clear he is going to be a force in the water for years to come.

Hmmm...people sure do forget that this idiot has a DUI. But that is okay because he can swim from here to there fast...so driving drunk is okay for him. Yeah right.

Not a chance, swimming is never on TV.

I don't think the comparison is fair to either athlete (Woods & Phelps). They are probably the best conditioned athletes their sport has ever seen, probably better conditioned than many athletes in other sports as well. However, the nearly year round nature of golf gives Mr. Woods far more consistent exposeure that Mr. Phelps will hever hope to see.

I would be hard pressed to say which is a better athlete becasue their sports have very different demands. However Phelps has made swimming more interesting than ever - which bennefits him and his sport.

As to the DWI comment - Phelps was a kid, doing what kids do - testing limits, feeling invincible, following his peers. He took responsibilty and seemingly has learned from that. Greatness isn't measured by never falling, but by rising every time one falls.

The 'roid abusers could learn a lesson from Mr. Phelps on that score.

NBC has the video on their website. Great stuff.

http://www.nbcolympics.com/swimming/video/index.html

Kevin,
Thank God we've found someone in this world who is mistake-free (and I'm confident you are the best in the world at your chosen sport or profession)! I have been gnashing my teeth over the fact that human beings seem destined to make mistakes...until you came along. I bow down to you, my Lord.

Now, back to reality. I would love to see more swimming on TV. I think it's ridiculous that the FINA championships weren't covered. Swimming is a very, very exciting sport, and these are true athletes. What can you say about Phelps unbelievable abilities, especially his turns? He's aquaman!

I do love me some Tiger Woods though!

My bad! That was Barney Gumble who is perfect... ;)

I admire this young man, i truely belive that he's a role model for our young people.
I'm from the caribbean island of St. Lucia and i look forward every four years for the olympics games especilly swimming. i believe that they should show more swimming prier to the olympics.

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

Please enter the letter "t" in the field below:
About the blogger
Kevin Van Valkenburg is a Montana native who has worked for The Baltimore Sun since 2000. He played football in college, albeit poorly and briefly. Since joining the Sun, he has covered everything from college football to figure skating to swimming in Australia. He likes cold beer, songs about broken hearts, the television show The Wire, hitting a 2-iron off the tee, and literature that keeps you up late at night. In 2005, a piece he wrote for the Sun was anthologized in the Best American Sports Writing series. He and his wife, Jen, live in Hampden and consider Natty Bohs, tater tots and turkey burgers from the Golden West to be the perfect meal.

About this blog
Most Recent Comments
-- ADVERTISEMENT --

Photo galleries
Blog updates
Recent updates to baltimoresun.com sports blogs  Subscribe to this feed