Such is life for a first-time CWS program and a coach who grew up a ground-rule double from the event's venerable home in Omaha, Neb.
Virginia lost two of three games in Omaha, including its opener to eventual champion LSU.
"It's much different this year," junior catcher John Hicks said.
Yes, the Cavaliers are back in the CWS, far better prepared for the distractions, obligations and competition.
"This time, we know what to expect," said Hultzen, Virginia's scheduled starter Sunday against California.
A first-team All-American and the No. 2 pick of the Major League draft, Hultzen started two CWS games as a freshman, without a decision. Hicks, third baseman Steven Proscia and second baseman Keith Werman also were in the lineup two seasons ago.
Then, the Cavaliers were college baseball's Owen Wilson and Vince Vaughn, crashing the high-society soirée. Now, they're the NCAA tournament's No. 1 seed, complete with a gaudy 54-10 record and fresh off a dramatic Super Regional victory over UC Irvine.
"Our players have earned this opportunity and they are very proud of it," said O'Connor, Virginia's eighth-year coach. "That being said, they understand that we are going there (with) a job to do, and (that) the goal has not been met."
The Cavaliers may lack a national championship, but they have played at that level all season.
They dropped consecutive games only once, in a three-game sweep at North Carolina, and rebounded immediately to win the ACC tournament. They lead the nation in ERA and winning percentage and rank fifth in fielding percentage, 16th in scoring.
"I'm not saying we expected to go (to the CWS)," Hicks said. "But we felt confident we were one of the best teams in the country."
That confidence was probably more prevalent inside Virginia's clubhouse than outside. After all, the Cavaliers lost starting outfielders Phil Gosselin, Dan Grovatt and Jarrett Parker, shortstop Tyler Cannon, catcher Franco Valdes and national saves leader Kevin Arico from a top-10 squad that came within one victory of the CWS.
O'Connor's recruiting and coaching overcame those departures as players such as shortstop Chris Taylor, closer Branden Kline, starting pitcher Will Roberts and outfielders John Barr, Kenny Swab and David Coleman embraced primary roles.
"So many guys in the lineup and on the mound have rose up for this team the entire season," O'Connor said.
O'Connor's Omaha homecoming was the dominant storyline two years ago. This time he's happy to be replaced by subplots such as the city's new stadium and Cal's return to the CWS for the first time in 19 years.
Cal announced Sept. 28 that baseball was among four sports being purged by budget cuts. But alums and boosters ponied up $9 million to save baseball, and the Golden Bears paid immeasurable dividends.
And if Virginia faithful think the Cavaliers' down-to-their-last strike escape against UC Irvine in the Super Regional was amazing, consider Cal.